Roll Over Image to Zoom

Spoonable Caramels

Get it while it's here! Items with prices ending in .99 are final sale.
No longer available

Top it off. Brooklyn-based Michelle Lewis makes decadent caramel sauces from the best ingredients and without preservatives. Rich and smooth, they make natural toppings for ice cream, cakes and waffles but also integrate beautifully into salad dressings or meat glazes.


  • 7.75 oz.
  • Preservative-free caramel sauces.
  • Flavors: Brooklyn Butterscotch, Chewy Sesame Caramel, Salty Traditional Sauce.
  • Drizzle over desserts, use in sauces and dressings or eat right out of the jar.
  • Sugar, cream, butter and other natural flavors. See Dimensions + Care for complete ingredients.
  • Made in Brooklyn, New York.
Details + Dimensions


  • Overall product size: 7.75 fluid oz.
  • Flavors: Brooklyn Butterscotch, Chewy Sesame Caramel and Salty Traditional Sauce.


  • Brooklyn Butterscotch: Sugar, cream, butter, golden syrup, molasses crystals, vanilla extract and sea salt.
  • Chewy Sesame Caramel: Sugar, heavy cream (milk), butter, water, sesame seeds, sea salt and sesame oil.
  • Salty Traditional Sauce: Sugar, cream, butter and sea salt.
Shipping + Return Info



These items ship from our Distribution Center by UPS and arrive in your home within 4-5 business days of order receipt.

Shipping Rates
The shipping rate varies depending on your order total and shipping options. View Shipping Rates and Options

Next Day Delivery
For an extra charge of $17.50 per address, we can arrange for rush delivery to most destinations.





We happily accept returns on stocked items within the time frames listed below. Products designated as special order (SPO) cannot be cancled or returned. All items on our website and in-store are considered ‘stocked’ unless expressly identified as ‘special order’ instead. Prior purchases are not eligible for price adjustments. Please familiarize yourself with our returns policy before placing your order.


Stocked Items: If you are dissatisfied with your purchase of a stocked item, you must exchange or return it within the following time frames for a full refund of the merchandise cost (delivery fees are non-refundable). Outside these time frames, we will replace or refund your purchase against manufacturer's defects ONLY. Please note that we cannot accept returns on gift cards or items damaged through normal wear and tear. We also cannot accept returns of final-sale items, which are identified by a price ending in .99 or .97.

  • Quick Ship upholstery items must be returned within 7 days of the order receipt date.
  • All other stocked products must be returned within 30 days of the order receipt date.


Special Order Items (SPO): Because they’re custom made to your specifications, special order items may not be canceled or returned and are exchangeable against manufacturer’s defects ONLY. SPO includes special order upholstery items, monogrammed/personalized items, special order rugs, one-of-a kind rugs and any products being shipped directly from a third-party vendor. Any special order items will be flagged as ‘special order’ in your shopping cart. NEW JERSEY CUSTOMERS: Special-order upholstered furniture returns are subject to applicable state law and are non-returnable after 24 hours of delivery.


For further assistance please call our customer service department at 1.888.922.4119 or send an email to



Choose Items


No longer available